Right, cards on table time.

I am a Christian. But I have no truck whatsoever with missionaries who seek to convert.

Equally, let me hasten to add, I take great exception to people not being allowed to convert if they so wish – which is a perennial issue here in India.

My view is that the decision to practise one’s religion or not, to convert to another faith or not, is a private one, and that outside bodies have absolutely no right to interfere.

So, having said that, let me share with you a tale of crass stupidity and ignorance and, in my opinion, western arrogance.

A young American missionary has allegedly been killed by tribals on a remote island in India.  He was trying to land on a tiny island, to which access is prohibited, intending to convert the inhabitants to Christianity.

Sorry if I offend anyone, but what arrogance.

Breaking the laws of India, getting the fishermen who took him there into trouble, and now presumed dead.

26 years of age.

Younger than my children.

Here’s the front page story from this morning’s Hindustan Times:

Mr. Chau was attacked on a previous attempt to land on the island, all of which he documented in his diary:

“…wrote of returning to the island to continue his attempts at conversion even after a tribesman shot at him with a bow and arrow, piercing a Bible he was carrying.

“I hollered, ‘My name is John, I love you and Jesus loves you,'” he wrote in his diary.”


Yet again, sorry for offending anyone out there etc., etc., but what errant nonsense.

As if the tribals, about whom next to nothing is known, precisely because there has been virtually no contact with them – as if the tribals, who are known to have killed other perceived intruders – would understand English.

Didn’t this young man do ANY research before embarking on what appears to be an almost Indiana-Jones-y kind of escapade?

Didn’t he read up about the isolation in which the North Sentinelese live?

Didn’t he understand that they are hostile towards intruders?

No-one knows for sure how many tribals there are, because no one has landed on the island, but young Mr. Chau, armed with his Bible, thought he could land and convert them.

I was prepared to write this sad, bizarre story off to youthful thoughtlessness, until I read the following extract from his diary:

“Lord, is this island Satan’s last stronghold where none have heard or even had the chance to hear your name?”


Because they’re not Christians?

If that isn’t ignorance wrapped up in arrogance, then I don’t know what is.

Here are a few facts about the Sentinelese, courtesy of CNN:

A sad end all round.

A youngster dead.

Fishermen who helped him now in trouble.

And a family back in the US grieving the loss of their child.


A story with absolutely no happy ending.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.